Comprehensive Evaluation of Medication Error Incidence in a Tertiary Care Hospital
735Views & Citations
Background: Medication errors are any preventable event that may cause patient harm while the medication is in control of healthcare professional. Medication reconciliation is a process of active monitoring to reduce the severity of sequelae due to unintended medication errors. The objectives are to assess the incidence of medication errors, to evaluate percentage of error prone abbreviations, to assess the incidence of adverse drug reactions.
Methods: A cross-sectional observational study was conducted for a period of 6 months February to July 2019.A systematic monitoring was done by the clinical pharmacist during regular ward rounds on medication errors, error prone abbreviations, and adverse drug reactions for all the drugs. The data was collected by examining patient’s case files using Medication reconciliation forms as a tool and data interpretation was done using Microsoft Excel 2010.
Results: A total of 4721 prescriptions were analysed, among which 254 medication errors were encountered (5.38%). On categorizing the same, it was observed to have 71 (27.95%) prescription errors, 5 (1.97%) administration errors, 124(48.82%) transcription errors, 11(4.33%) dispensing errors, 11(4.33%) monitoring errors and 14 (5.51%) drug duplications. Apart from medication errors, 18 (0.38%) Error Prone Abbreviations and 18 (0.38%) adverse drug reactions were also noted.
Conclusion: Medication errors can be prevented by giving attention to the medication therapy and increased involvement of clinical pharmacists in the provision of pharmaceutical care, results in improved patient outcomes and an overall reduction in health care costs. Hence Pharmacist collaborating with other health care providers will further improve patient safety.Keywords: Medication errors, Transcription errors, Prescription errors, Error prone abbreviations, Adverse drug reactions.
Medication error is defined as “any preventable event that may cause or lead to inappropriate medication use or patient harm while the medication is in the control of the health care professional, patient, or consumer” . Errors can occur in any stage in the sequence of mediation use. Errors happen due to lack of knowledge, poor performance and psychological lapses [2, 3]. It arises when an action is anticipated but not performed .
Medication errors can be understood based on various classifications as contextual, modal or psychological . This study classifies errors based on the stages of medication use process, such as prescribing, administration, transcribing, dispensing and monitoring Table 1.
Error prone abbreviations are another significant source of medication error contributed by the use of inappropriate abbreviations in prescriptions. It is a malpractice frequently causing harm to the patients . The incidence of error prone abbreviations is higher in handwritten prescriptions when compared to the electronic ones. In developing countries standardizing acceptable abbreviations is necessary to eliminate error prone abbreviations .
An Adverse drug reaction (ADR) is an unwanted or harmful response experienced following the administration of a drug or a combination of drugs under normal conditions of use. It is suspected to be related to the drug and medication errors may Medication misadventure can happen anywhere in the healthcare system and it is a threat to effective patient care. The sequelae of an unintended medication error may include iatrogenic adverse drug reaction, prolonged hospital stay, morbidity or even death . Clinical pharmacists can have a significant impact on reducing healthcare costs, as they have the expertise to detect, resolve, and prevent medication errors and medication-related problems, promoting efficient patient care.
The primary objectives of this study are to assess the incidence of medication errors, to evaluate percentage of error prone abbreviations, to assess the incidence of adverse drug reactions.
A cross-sectional observational retrospective study was conducted for a period of 6 months (Feb- July 2019) in an inpatient setting of Frontier Lifeline Hospital, Chennai.
Study Criteria Inclusion
- Patients of both genders
- Included all age group of patients
- Patient admitted in Inpatient department
- Outpatient department
Study tools: Medication reconciliation forms were used as a tool to document all the error data.
A systematic monitoring was done by the clinical pharmacist during daily ward rounds on medication errors, error prone abbreviations, adverse drug reactions for all drugs and special attention was given for high risk medications, look alike sound alike drugs, restricted antimicrobial and narcotics. The data was collected on examining patient’s case files and on analyzing laboratory investigations, drug chart and daily doctor’s progress report. All the error data were documented using medication reconciliation form and the same was submitted to the quality improvement. The data was analyzed using Microsoft Excel 2010.
We reviewed 4721 medication orders and found 254 medication errors (5.38%), 18 error-prone abbreviations
(0.38%), 18 adverse drug reactions (0.38%).
TYPES OF MEDICATION ERRORS
A total of 4721 prescriptions were analysed, among which 254 medication errors were encountered (5.38%). On categorizing the same, it was observed to have 71(27.95%) prescription errors, 5(1.97%) administration errors, 124(48.82%) transcription errors, 11(4.33%) dispensing errors, 11(4.33%) monitoring errors, 14 (5.51%) drug duplications and 18 (7.09%) error-prone abbreviations as mentioned in Figure 1, Table 2.
Out of 4721 medication orders we found 254 medication errors (5.38%) in a span of 6 months. During the study duration the highest incidence of medication errors were observed in April and the lowest in July as seen in Figure 2, Table 3.
ERROR PRONE ABBREVIATIONS
We reviewed 254 medication errors and found 18 Error-prone Abbreviation (0.38%) in a span of 6 months of which we found highest percentage of medication error-prone abbreviations in February and lowest percentage of medication error- prone abbreviations in July as depicted in Figure 3 and Table 4.
We reviewed 4721 medication orders of which 18 (0.38%) adverse drug reactions were found in a span of 6 months. Highest percentage of adverse drug reactions were observed in July and followed by April, and lowest was seen in May as in Figure 4, Table 5.
Medication errors have the potential to cause harm in the patients hence it’s monitoring and assessment is an important task to promote healthcare. Unfortunately, there is a huge gap in monitoring the medication errors globally and specifically in India. With that as consideration, this study was conducted to assess the type and frequency of medication errors in a tertiary care hospital in Chennai . Our study reported higher incidence of transcription errors 124 (48.82%) similar to the study of Lisby M et al., The process of transcribing a drug order manually from one sheet is a significant source of error due to negligence and omission. Transcription errors can potentially compromise patient outcomes [15-17]. Prescribing errors 71 (27.95%) were the most frequent category of medication errors occurred in patients followed by administration errors. High rate of prescribing errors might be due to peak hour and patient load leading to lack of attention by the healthcare team, which could affect the patient treatment, increase the hospital stay, and further cause an economic burden to hospital as well as patients .
In this study we also aimed to observe the use of error-prone abbreviations and other inappropriately used abbreviations in prescriptions. A total of 18 (0.38%) error-prone abbreviations were noted in the study. Pharmacists who are involved in interpreting prescriptions should explain that this erratic use of abbreviations may lead to medication errors. Even though the incidence is very less, eradicating error-prone abbreviations is important to avoid the effects of preventable medication errors [19, 20]. Advancing technology to use electronic prescription has greatly reduced this problem [21-24]. In developing countries hospitals that use hand-written prescriptions should inform prescribers of this danger and develop in-house error- prone abbreviations list for their guidance and promote, the use of standardised, acceptable abbreviations. This fact is supported by studies of Samaranayake NR et al., and Miasso AI et al [25-28].
It was observed that 18 (0.38%) adverse drug reactions were seen during the study. Medication errors are strong risk factors for preventable adverse drug events or reactions, strategies have to be made for their reduction [29-32]. Such strategies include ensuring that all persons involved in the medication process i.e. the physicians; nurses and pharmacists must have good pharmacological knowledge, computerisation of the entire medication process, and the engagement of a sufficient number of clinical pharmacists on the wards to monitor the same. This was supported by M Alshakka et al.
Medication errors can be prevented by giving attention to the medication therapy and increased involvement of clinical pharmacists in the provision of pharmaceutical care. It results in improved patient outcomes and an overall reduction in health care costs. The incidence of medication errors can be overcome by educating physicians, nurses and other healthcare professionals regarding the areas where medication errors are prone to occur and develop strategies to avoid the same.
National Coordinating Council for Medication Error Reporting and Prevention (2015) What is a medication error New York, NY: National Coordinating Council for Medication Error Reporting and Prevention. Available online at: https://nccmerp.org/about-medication- errors
Aspden P, Aspden P (2007) Preventing Medication Errors. Washington, DC: The National Academies
Hugar SM, Suganya M, Vikneshan M, Kiran K (2014) Medication errors and its implications in pediatric dentistry. Indian J Oral Sci 5(1): 27-32.
McDowell SE, Ferner HS, Ferner RE (2009) The pathophysiology of medication errors: How and where they Br J Clin Pharmacol 67(6): 605-613.
Ambwani S, Misra AK, Kumar R (2019) Medication errors: Is it the hidden part of the submerged iceberg in our health-care system? Int J Appl Basic Med Res 9(3): 135-142.
Velo GP, Minuz P (2009) Medication errors: Prescribing faults and prescription Br J Clin Pharmacol 67(6): 624-628.
Feleke SA, Mulatu MA, Yesmaw YS (2015) Medication administration error: magnitude and associated factors among nurses in BMC Nursing 14(1): 53
- Cheung KC, Bouvy ML, De Smet PA (2009) Medication errors: the importance of safe dispensing. Br J Clin Pharmacol 67(6): 676-680.
- Therapeutic Duplication (2020) org.
- Samaranayake NR, Dabare PR, Wanigatunge CA, Cheung BM (2014) The pattern of abbreviation use in prescriptions: A way forward in eliminating error-prone abbreviations and standardisation of prescriptions. Curr drug safety 9(1): 34-42.
- Dooley MJ, Wiseman M, Gu G (2012) Prevalence of error‐prone abbreviations used in medication prescribing for hospitalised patients: Multi-hospital Intern Med J 42(3): e19-22.
- Adverse drug reactions (2020) Pharmacology education project [Internet]. Pharmacologyeducation.org. Available online at: https://www.pharmacologyeducation.org/clinical- pharmacology/adverse-drug-reactions
- Ramesh G, Sundeep K, Anitha C, Malika S, Samyuktha KR, Sharmila SK, Babu PS. Incidence of Medication Errors in a Tertiary Care Hospital in South-India. Indian Journal of Pharmacy Practice 12(2): 92-96.
- Dedefo MG, Mitike AH, Angamo MT (2016) Incidence and determinants of medication errors and adverse drug events among hospitalized children in West Ethiopia. BMC Pediatr 16: 81
- Lisby M, Nielsen LP, Mainz J (2005) Errors in the medication process: Frequency, type, and potential clinical International journal for quality in health care 17(1): 15-22.
- Hartel MJ, Staub LP, Röder C, Eggli S (2011) High incidence of medication documentation errors in a Swiss university hospital due to the handwritten prescription process. BMC Health Serv Res 11(1):
- Brennan TA, Leape LL, Laird NM, Hebert L, Localio AR, et al. (1991) Incidence of adverse events and negligence in hospitalized patients: Results of the harvard medical practice study N Engl J Med 324(6): 370-376.
- Patel RR, Karelia BN (2018) Detecting medication errors from adverse drug reaction monitoring centre database - a retrospective analysis. Int J Pharm Sci Res 9(6): 2520- 2524
- Samaranayake NR, Dabare PR, Wanigatunge CA, Cheung BM (2014) The pattern of abbreviation uses in prescriptions: A way forward in eliminating error-prone abbreviations and standardisation of prescriptions. Curr Drug Safety 9(1): 34-42.
- The Joint Commission (2004) Facts about the official ‘Do Not Use’
Miasso AI, Oliveira RC, Silva AE, Junior DPL, Gimenes FR, et (2009) Prescription errors in Brazilian hospitals: A multi-centre exploratory survey. Cadernos de Saúde Pública 25: 313-20.
Alshakka M, Saeed GMA, Ali H, Prajapati SK, Ibrahim MI (2019) Adverse drug reactions and medication errors: A quantitative insight in aden, yemen. J Young Pharm 11(1).
Keezhipadathil J (2019) Evaluation of suspected adverse drug reactions of oral anti-diabetic drugs in a tertiary care hospital for type ii diabetes mellitus. Indian Journal of Pharmacy Practice 12(2):
Sudhakar R, George MK, Yasaswini B, Sundararajan N, Mariyam AS (2016) Adverse drug reactions associated with anti-hypertensive drugs and its management. Int J Pharm Sci Res 7(3):
Vikas S, Ramesh M, Rani VN, Thennarasu P, Kannan G (2017) Incidence of diuretics induced adverse drug reactions in an intensive cardiac care unit of a tertiary care teaching Int J Pharm Sci Res 8(8): 3557-3562.
Grimes T, Delaney T, Duggan C, Kelly JG, Graham IM (2008) Survey of medication documentation at hospital discharge: Implications for patient safety and continuity of care. Ir J Med Sci 177(2): 93-97.
Cornu P, Steurbaut S, Leysen T, De Baere E, Ligneel C, et (2012) Discrepancies in medication information for the primary care physician and the geriatric patient at discharge. Ann Pharmacother 46(7-8): 983-990.
Geurts MM, Flier MVD, Bots AMDV, Wal TIBVD, de Gier JJ (2013) Medication reconciliation to solve discrepancies in discharge documents after discharge from the Int J Clin Pharm 35(4): 600-607
Stitt DM, Elliott DP, Thompson SN (2011) Medication discrepancies identified at time of hospital discharge in a geriatric population. Am J Geriatr Pharmacother 9(4): 234-240.
Sluisveld NV, Zegers M, Natsch S, Wollersheim H (2012) Medication reconciliation at hospital admission and discharge: Insufficient knowledge, unclear task reallocation and lack of collaboration as major barriers to medication BMC Health Serv Res 12: 170
Shibeshi W (2015) Reconciliation of medication discrepancies at hospital discharge for inpatients in medical ward of Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Ann Clin Lab Res 3: 4.
Magalhães GF, Santos GN, Rosa MB, Noblat Lde A (2014) Medication reconciliation in patients hospitalized in a cardiology unit. PLoS One 9: e115491